Failure of a Hadith with Respect to Its Chain of Transmission (Isnad) and Its Impact on Acting Upon It Among Early and Later Scholars: An Applied Critical Hadith Study

Authors

  • Mustafa Makhlouf Abdallah Benghuzzi Libyan Academy, Department of Islamic Studies, Misrata, Libya Author

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.65420/476d0d18

Keywords:

Isnad, Matn, Weak Hadith, Fabricated Hadith, Corroborating Chains, Hadith Criticism, Acting upon Hadith, Early Scholars

Abstract

This research examines a foundational issue in the criticism of Prophetic Hadith, specifically the relationship between the authentication of the chain of transmission (Isnad) and the validity of the text (Matn), alongside the implications of discovering the weakness of a narration by later scholars (Muta'akhkhirun) after earlier scholars (Mutaqaddimun) had transmitted or acted upon its content. The study addresses two central questions: Does the failure of a specific Isnad necessarily invalidate the Matn entirely? And how should the scholarly efforts of earlier authorities be evaluated when a narration they relied upon is later deemed weak? Utilizing inductive, analytical, and comparative critical methodologies, the paper argues that while Isnad and Matn criticism are interconnected, the weakness of a single chain does not automatically negate the validity of the general meaning or the existence of other independent, corroborating chains (Mutaba'at and Shawahid) that may elevate the narration to Hasan li-ghayrihi. Furthermore, the research distinguishes between establishing the literal attribution of a statement to the Prophet (peace be upon him), the intrinsic soundness of its meaning under broader Islamic principles, and the permissibility of acting upon weak Hadiths in virtuous deeds (Fada'il al-A'mal) under strict scholarly conditions. Through applied critical case studies of four widely circulated narrations—including "My companions are like the stars" and "Religion is intellect"—the paper concludes that rigorous verification in attributing texts to the Prophet is essential, while fairness and academic integrity must govern the assessment of earlier scholars' Ijtihad, preventing Hadith discrepancies from becoming tools for unfounded disparagement.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

Downloads

Published

2026-10-29

Issue

Section

Articles

How to Cite

Mustafa Makhlouf Abdallah Benghuzzi. (2026). Failure of a Hadith with Respect to Its Chain of Transmission (Isnad) and Its Impact on Acting Upon It Among Early and Later Scholars: An Applied Critical Hadith Study . Comprehensive Journal of Humanities and Educational Studies, 2(4), 169-176. https://doi.org/10.65420/476d0d18